Choosing the right structural material for your detached garage is critical for longevity and performance, especially given Utah’s demanding climate of extreme heat, intense sun, and deep cold. This comparison focuses on the core structural integrity of the most common materials used in the Salt Lake area.
|
Material |
Pros (For Utah’s Climate) |
Cons |
Our Recommendation |
|
Traditional Wood Framing |
Cost-effective, readily available, allows for seasonal movement, easy to modify later. |
Susceptible to rot, pests (termite), requires kiln-dried lumber to minimize shrinkage and warping from moisture changes. |
A durable, cost-effective option, but requires proper moisture and pest mitigation. |
|
Steel Framing |
Superior Longevity: Does not shrink, warp, rot, or attract pests. Non-Combustible. Excellent strength-to-weight ratio. |
Higher Upfront Cost compared to wood. Requires special tools for modifications; can conduct heat/cold if not properly insulated. |
Ideal for Workshops/Auto Bays: Offers the highest durability and consistency for long-term use. |
|
Concrete Block (CMU) |
Excellent Insulation (Thermal Mass): Handles weather extremes well by slowing heat transfer. Highly durable, fire, and pest resistant. |
Highest Upfront Cost. Labor-intensive installation. Requires proper vapor barrier and interior finishing. |
Best for Finished Spaces/ADUs: Provides superior interior climate control and sound isolation. |
Tying Structure to Finish
Our specialization in durable construction extends beyond the frame. For any material choice, we recommend and use a reinforced concrete floor that provides a stable, long-lasting base.
- Concrete Flooring: Essential for longevity, a quality slab resists moisture, supports heavy vehicles/equipment, and is the perfect substrate for durable polyaspartic coatings, which further protect it from Utah’s temperature swings and chemical spills.
The best material is the one that aligns with your budget and your long-term goals. For the ultimate in durability and freedom from maintenance, Steel Framing is a strong contender for structural integrity in the Intermountain West.
Invest in Materials That Last
Your garage’s framework dictates its durability, maintenance needs, and long-term value. Whether you prioritize the cost-effectiveness of treated wood, the sheer resilience of steel, or the thermal mass of concrete block, our expertise ensures the right material is selected and installed to withstand Utah’s severe climate. We build structures that require less maintenance and deliver greater peace of mind.
Ready to choose the right materials for your long-lasting garage? Contact Dave Johnson Construction today for a free, detailed material cost breakdown.
Need experts to demolish your old garage and build a new one?
We are a local full service garage enhancement company. Our goal is to provide homeowners with impeccable work and undeniable results.
G-L0511C8SY6
Skip to content